Two Views on Romans 9

Everyone agrees that Romans 9 teaches the doctrine of election. But how exactly does Paul understand this doctrine? Here is a graphic I created to explain two very different interpretations of the chapter:

I believe interpretation B is superior to interpretation A for several reasons, but the following three are the most important:

1) In Rom 9:6-9, Paul is returning again to an argument he already made in Rom 2:28-29 and 4:9-16: the true heirs of promise are not merely the physical descendants of Abraham but rather all who follow in the faith of Abraham.

2) Paul argues in Rom 9:10-18 that election is independent of works, but he never argues that election is independent of faith.

3) Paul will state explicitly in Rom 11:7-14 that those individuals who are currently “hardened” and not “elect” may still be saved. 

Looking for a way to keep up your Greek or Hebrew? Daily Greek and Hebrew uses simple multiple-choice quizzes to guide you through the analysis and translation of one verse every day. Click on the image below to get started!